Nov. 18, 2026

Ep. 2024: Your House Is Not Your Portfolio

Ep. 2024: Your House Is Not Your Portfolio
Talking Real Money
Ep. 2024: Your House Is Not Your Portfolio

Is your home really your best investment? Don and Tom compare decades of after-tax housing returns with the S&P 500, including the costs, illiquidity, and lifestyle value that make a house a place to live—not a retirement portfolio.

They also answer questions about retiring with a 401(k) loan, plan-specific repayment rules, and why Roth-conversion taxes are usually better paid from cash or a brokerage account.

00:45 A home or the companies that build everything?
04:03 Real estate versus stocks
09:21 The liquidity problem
14:20 Keep housing and investing separate
16:35 Retiring with a 401(k) loan
22:24 How to pay Roth-conversion taxes
27:09 RMD percentages at age 75

Questions? Comments? Click!

00:50 - Homeownership: Lifestyle or Investment?

04:02 - Real Estate Versus Stocks: The Numbers

09:21 - The Hidden Costs and Illiquidity of Homeownership

09:42 - Why Homeowners Value Stability

11:09 - Renting, Saving, and Your Home’s Equity

15:13 - Listener Q&A: Retirement Plan Loans

21:25 - A Cosmic Extinction and a Short Story

22:23 - Listener Q&A: Paying Roth Conversion Taxes

28:51 - Wrap-Up, Listener Questions, and Sign-Off

30:19 - Important Financial Disclosures

SPEAKER_01

A cowboy bought a cabin with a fence around the yard. Put every dime he had in it, and guards it mighty hard. The roof leaked in the springtime, then the taxman came and fought. One little fenced and patch of land. Ain't hardly much at all. So keep your cozy cabin partner, hang your hat and stay. And let your money ride the range a thousand miles away. On the whole dark market, every herd and every hand making money make sense. All across the land. Talking real money.

SPEAKER_03

Talking real money.

SPEAKER_05

So, partners, it's better to get that there, Little House on the Prairie or Home,

Homeownership: Lifestyle or Investment?

SPEAKER_05

Home on the Range? Or is it better to invest in the people who build the Little House on the Prairie and deliver the range? And the television and the fiber optic cable and the phone and the things that you deal with every single day, every other product that's making money somewhere in the world. Which is a better investment? Well, a lot of people would say it's that doggone house that's the best investment. Just buy real estate and don't do nothing else. Well, we're here to tell you the whole story on what we call talking real money. Hi, everybody, I'm Don. That's Tom over there in Washington. I'm in Florida. Neither of us are out on the prairie.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, kind of close. I'm you know you're out there where that music is more popular than it would be in your neighborhood.

SPEAKER_05

Oh, are you kidding? We're like Redneck Villa down here. Dude, have you seen all the things?

SPEAKER_02

You sound like it in a Disney sponsored.

SPEAKER_05

Okay, a Disney sponsor, not this town, but Florida, I'm just saying.

SPEAKER_02

It's a dream state.

SPEAKER_05

That's more cowboy. That song was, you know, that that one resonates in the heartland.

SPEAKER_02

Yes.

SPEAKER_05

It does.

SPEAKER_02

Which I'm, as you know, I can see the heartland from where I am. You can't point in it, but I can see it.

SPEAKER_05

Well, if you just drive down the road, you go to that land of contented cows at Carnation, Washington. Wasn't that the slogan of Carnation Milk? I don't know.

SPEAKER_02

I'm gonna let you say that. So I think that's conceited cows? No, contented cows. I seem to remember Co-tented cows? I don't think so. Okay. I'm gonna just say no. That's not it was never anybody's that's a horrible brand. I'm telling you, I remember content like happy with the amount of grass they're getting or something, or they love the floodwaters.

SPEAKER_05

Which part of it is that they Carnation Wait, hold on, hold on. Okay, the Pacific Coast Condensed Milk Company changed its name to Carnation. Okay? Yeah. And their iconic slogan that they created in 1907 was That's why I didn't know it. Milk from Contented Cows. You're the only guy who remembers that because the only guy old enough to remember that slogan. No, I think they still do it.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, come on. And really?

SPEAKER_05

Um yeah.

SPEAKER_02

Who cares if the cows are contented?

SPEAKER_05

Dude, dude. Um there there one of the the uh leaders of the firm uh wrote a book called Contented Cows Still Give Better Milk.

SPEAKER_02

That sounds like a page turner, but I'm gonna let you to it there, partner. If I call you a partner, don't you doubt me? I'm gonna you're gonna you're gonna you'll find me wrong no matter what it is. I will too. In fact, I'm looking at the case. Take you all day on the range, but it won't matter. Yeah, here we go. Can we get to the story here?

SPEAKER_05

Here's a carnation evaporated milk label, and it says it's carnation milk and up at the top.

SPEAKER_02

I know what it looks like from contented cows. Okay. I you know what? And I want you, since you believe that, to confirm that. I want you to go do some interviews. I want you to study.

SPEAKER_05

I want to get you some we're gonna do a find out podcast. But right now, we're

Real Estate Versus Stocks: The Numbers

SPEAKER_05

not gonna do the cow. Right now, we're gonna do the real estate versus stock argument, the the the debate that never ends.

SPEAKER_02

Well, you said that you said an interesting thing there. Invest in and you mentioned home in the same sentence. I think as just as a rule, we should all get rid of the whole idea that your home is an investment. It's a bad idea. Your home's a place to live, home's a place to enjoy the lifestyle you want. Um, could it provide a return of some amount? Not much compared to other things. Let's put it that way.

SPEAKER_05

Well, let's look at the numbers. What are the numbers? You you better be able to back this up with some evidence, sir.

SPEAKER_02

Because the bovine beauty is gonna come and get me real fast if I don't, huh? Run right through the gate. Uh, all right. Well, this is a new study that's out. Uh 40 years of data, which is still not that much, but it's still 40 years, right? Um, and what they did was they looked at either purchasing a home back to 1985, purchasing a home, uh a hundred thousand dollar home with 20% down, or putting that money in the S P 500. Now, the home, they also do things like subtracting taxes, your mortgage costs, et cetera, et cetera. The money in the SP 500, they they they subtract out taxes federally and locally, right? So they try to give it a balance here to see what's better. And by the way, uh, not to brag or anything, but the best returning marketplace in the entire United States of America with those bovine, contented bovines or not.

SPEAKER_05

By the way, they used that label up until Nestle acquired them in 1985. So you were still just you were definitely around. You just never bought contented cow milk, did you?

SPEAKER_02

I don't think I use a lot of condensed milk. So maybe in the cookies.

SPEAKER_05

Well, there's evaporated, too. There's evaporated.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, that's the one I'm thinking of. It comes in that little can, I think.

SPEAKER_05

Well, so does condensed. So they both come in the little can.

SPEAKER_02

I use it once a year to make some cookies, I think, or something. But anyway, to brag it up, the post-tax returns. Real estate. You're milking every doggone thing you can out of this, aren't you? Uh post-tax returns, the highest return. Real estate?

SPEAKER_05

Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

Great here in Seattle. Apparently, those cows are so contented to be on that expensive real estate 6.2% annually. San Diego is next, 6.0. Los Angeles, 5.9. Okay? Right?

SPEAKER_05

Right.

SPEAKER_02

That sounds good.

SPEAKER_05

It sounds good.

SPEAKER_02

That's before inflation. No, pardon me. No, yes, that's before inflation.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, it's before inflation.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah. S P 500, 7.5.

SPEAKER_05

That's doesn't seem like as big a spread as I was thinking.

SPEAKER_02

The spread was, you know, like 1.3% a year. It adds up a year.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, but the thing is, is that isn't stock more volatile? Stock is more volatile. And by the way, you more liquid. You are you are cherry picking. You are data mining. Data mining. Yes. Because you're using the best cities. What about the how did the worst perform?

SPEAKER_02

I didn't even write those down.

SPEAKER_05

Oh, the worst performing.

SPEAKER_02

St. Louis. Yeah. Fly over USA. How's St. Louis? 3.88%? 3.8%, yeah.

SPEAKER_05

And that's just barely over inflation. Houston at 4.04%, Dallas at 4.22, Cincinnati at 4.22, Chicago at 4.22. So the Midwest has uh underperformed the market even more. But here's the thing there's another downside to you know it was funny. I was playing with the numbers on my house because I bought it 30 years ago for like 375,000. And today it's worth about 1.2 million. Yep. But I've also put a quarter of a million into it roofs, air conditioners, uh a new second story and part of the house, all those kinds of things. So the return um is I have really I I run the numbers. I've just about matched inflation.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, we talked about this when I sold my place here in the Northwest two years ago, right? And I thought I made a ton of money because I bought it in you know 2007, the market was riding high, market went straight down, went way back up. But we're gonna Yeah, and you bought high too. I did buy high. So I if I'd bought a year later, I'd have done better. But still the overall before inflation return was like 4%. Was not great. Um, they're saying that there's a lot of reasons why, by the way, real estate uh the the cost of buying and selling real estate, right? Commissions, closing costs, moving fees, all that kind of stuff is kind of spendy. If you want to sell the S P 500, doesn't cost a whole lot. Actually costs darn near nothing. Um Helms, you just mentioned some of the some of the maintenance you've done. There's property tax, homeowner insurance. Oh, don't you have HOA dues in your neighborhood too?

SPEAKER_05

Oh, yes, we do. But they're below the national average. Okay. I keep trying to tell my constituents that, even though we raised them a lot recently, they're still below the national average for HOAs. And we're a very highfalutin HOA.

SPEAKER_02

Don McMillan is still below the national average. That's what I tell people all the time. Still below the national average. And here's the other part of real estate that that I think gets.

SPEAKER_05

Wait, you say that about me personally?

The Hidden Costs and Illiquidity of Homeownership

SPEAKER_02

Doesn't get the attention it deserves. Extreme illiquidity.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_05

That's a big one. That's a big one.

SPEAKER_02

Tougher, by the way, if you hadn't noticed.

SPEAKER_05

If I want to sell my S P 500, I can sell it instantly. I can sell it in the next 30 seconds. You can get your money and if I want to get the equity out of my house.

Why Homeowners Value Stability

SPEAKER_02

Now here's the things that make people want to be homeowners. The the idea that you're sort of forced into saving, right? Because you are in a way, you're paying your mortgage. That's a forced savings program. You're you're paying down what you owe on that house, hopefully an appreciating asset. Well, appreciation's been mild.

SPEAKER_05

I hope you're paying it down is if you're not if you weren't over the years borrowing to do all those repairs on the house.

SPEAKER_02

Here's the other one that I think is way overrated. Uh psychological stability. People just feel better about owning the place that they live. And I get that. I truly get that because you've never left that room in 30 years.

SPEAKER_05

We have been in this house over 29 years. We bought it 30 years ago. We started construction 30 years ago. Wow. And there's no way, no way that I would have spent almost 30 years in a rental.

SPEAKER_02

I just wouldn't.

SPEAKER_05

You would have moved on. Because well, because the people who own the rental want to move on. Rentals are far they are far less stable. Far less stable. Sure.

SPEAKER_02

You may have to be able to do that.

SPEAKER_05

I mean, you know, apartments get converted to condos, and you either have to buy it or move out. So uh the stability, the psychological aspect, that I think is the number one differentiator. Because otherwise, looking at the numbers, real estate doesn't look like a it looks like a reasonable investment. I mean it's not a bad one, but it's not a good one either.

Renting, Saving, and Your Home’s Equity

SPEAKER_02

I don't think you should look. I think housing should be housing and investing should be investing. But here's some of the comments. I love reading these on the Wall Street Journal. And by the way, I hope you got some comments back because I I use your name and I mentioned a few things in this article.

SPEAKER_05

I always get comments and they're at some. John McDonald said because we uh never mind. I got it for the I got it for for the show and it's got my name on it. Use his name. He gets the paper because I don't love I don't want the paper. Yeah, it's a lot of paper. Tom wants the paper. Is there a theme running throughout this program?

SPEAKER_02

Paper, paper, paper.

SPEAKER_05

Tom I like to read my paper online. He doesn't.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah. I read I do both, but um I love these comments. First of all, someone wrote, You can't live in the S P 500. Oh something to that. Right?

SPEAKER_05

You can live on the income from the S P 500.

SPEAKER_02

Um somebody else wrote a home is not an investment. I think that's wise. There was a 40-something renter. He said, I'm a 40-something renter, and guess what? I have three million dollars saved.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

Because I haven't plowed it all in this house, right? I didn't buy one. I don't spend it on money, blah, blah, blah. I think that's going to be.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, I did also run the number and I just just rent it for 30 years to make it a simple number. If I had just taken 500,000, basically what I have in the house. How much? Um 8.5 million in the S P 500.

SPEAKER_02

We would be out partying every day with that.

SPEAKER_05

My house is worth probably 1.2 million. That's crazy.

SPEAKER_02

That's crazy. So housing is housing, lifestyle. We talk about this a lot when it comes to buying a house. Really should be lifestyle, not profit. It's not, you're not trying to get rich.

SPEAKER_05

And I have to tell you, personally, I do not. I mean, I know it's part of my net worth, the equity that supposedly exists in my house.

SPEAKER_02

Ah, thank you.

SPEAKER_05

But it's not part of our plan.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah.

SPEAKER_05

Because it would require selling and moving.

SPEAKER_02

Not necessarily. You could get a HELOC. I mean a HELOC. You could get a HELOC, but you could also get a reverse mortgage.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah. What no.

SPEAKER_02

Why do you say no out of hand? For some people it makes sense.

SPEAKER_05

Not for me.

SPEAKER_02

Okay. But I'm just saying there's money there that you you can't get to all of it, by the way.

SPEAKER_05

No, you can't get to all of it.

SPEAKER_02

Still relatively expensive, although not crazy if that's where your money is. Um not a good idea. By the way, I'm in the same spot as you, but that's my Alamo. Everything blows up. I'll either sell the place, get the money, or borrow against it.

SPEAKER_05

Um Sir, just a little note. You know, people talk like that about how it's my last resort. Um, if everything blows up, nothing is worth anything.

SPEAKER_02

Nah, I mean like every all my liquid stuff stops.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, but if all your liquid needs all those go to zero, yeah. Your house is gonna be pretty much worthless. Oh, you think so? Who's gonna have money to buy it?

SPEAKER_02

Okay. Well, I'll just I'll take one of those rafts, sit out in the middle of the lake, and you know, do whatever.

SPEAKER_05

Well, you know, you do have the advantage of being able to go fishing should things get bad.

SPEAKER_02

My wife, I we have our grandsons this Friday. I go, what should you do? You go, you should take them out on the paddleboard. I go, I am not falling off the paddleboard into a 50-degree lake. No. On the paddle board in that water?

SPEAKER_05

Oh, I thought she meant like a paddle boat. No, paddle board. Paddle board. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, she just wants to see you go in. That's what it is.

SPEAKER_02

I was like, and I'm not gonna go rescue somebody else in 50-degree weather either. Uh, so I this is I think this is important because I think, again, this is something that we have talked a lot about over the years. When housing markets heat up, people think I'm gonna get rich in my home. Don't plan on that. Number two, you've got to set aside, you've got to figure it out how to be that 40-year-old renter. You've got to put money aside in liquid things like the SP. That's not the SP 500, not the only place to invest. And quit, I like what you just said a minute ago. Quit thinking that I'm rich because I have all this equity in my home. It's hard to get to unless you want to move or unless you want to figure out how to borrow against it.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah. But you got to think about that. Where okay, I I'll sell it. Where where am I going?

SPEAKER_02

Yeah.

SPEAKER_05

Are you gonna just go from the I'll move in with them? You're just gonna go from the frying pan to another frying pan?

SPEAKER_02

That sounds warmer

Listener Q&A: Retirement Plan Loans

SPEAKER_02

than the paddle board, by the way.

SPEAKER_05

A lot.

unknown

Okay.

SPEAKER_05

Now, is it question time? Do you have questions for us today? Yeah, people send questions in. Tom turned them into paper.

SPEAKER_02

Paper. Paper. Thank you for your suggestions about how I can just read them off my computer. I by the way, can I finish that thought because I feel like I get unduly criticized by you and others.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah. Well, I don't know about unduly, but I think it's fair, but okay.

SPEAKER_02

Here's the thing about the reason behind the paper. All right, because we'll let's just let's just get this out there. I'm gonna put it out there. It's way easier for me to print the questions and then keep them in the proper order in which they come in than it is just on my computer. And maybe that's me. I'm just not organized enough.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, there's actually on your computer there's a notes app, and you can drag them and drop them into that app.

SPEAKER_02

Which note, like a D or a C, which note would you do on that?

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, that was that was a really, really weak attempt at a dad joke, ladies and gentlemen, for those of you who missed it at home.

SPEAKER_02

Uh I so appreciate. I still love looking at the tape of Retire Meet Last Year when you said that was a joke. So everybody knew. Well, because nobody laughed. I know, nobody laughed. Everybody laughed there. I went, what was what was that?

SPEAKER_05

I I saw a lot of nods, like okay, Tom.

SPEAKER_02

Leave him alone and nod alone.

SPEAKER_05

That was a joke. Like they say in the South. Bless his heart.

SPEAKER_02

Bless his heart. Bless his heart. He's doing his best.

SPEAKER_05

Oh, he's trying his best.

SPEAKER_02

All right, you ready for the papas? Yes, bless your podcast. All right. Port Orchard, Washington, Robert writes, try to keep brief. I don't know if he's referring to us right now. Might be us. Uh he says, I'm 56 and want to retire next year. Wait, I didn't read that very wait, 56?

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, that means he wants to retire. 57, Tom, just to do the math for you.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, listen, I don't want to think about it. Been with one company for 31 years, have two different retirement accounts under the same umbrella with my employer. One is traditional 401k. That means you say pre-tax. That means the money's gonna come out and you're gonna pay tax on it. And the other is a money purchase pension plan.

SPEAKER_05

Oh, okay. So that's a defined benefit plan.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, you they throw in, I think it's he says 10% of the salary each year, then you're gonna get a pension. Combined, he says they're about $2.3 million, both about the same amount. Here's the rub. We just finished building our dream home and have to dip into the $401k with a $50,000 loan. Question Barring no issues with my employer to take early retirement, does the loan have to be repaid before I can start taking out of the retirement? If yes, is it possible to take from the pension plan to pay the 401k loan back?

SPEAKER_04

Oh my god.

SPEAKER_02

As it is now, the way the payments are set up, won't be paid off until 2034. This, I did a little work on this because it's a good thing.

SPEAKER_05

Oh good, because I don't think I know the answer to this.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, it's kind of complicated. It this comes down sadly to the plan. Every dog on one of these is idiosyncratic. Yeah, they all got their own rules and blah, blah, blah. So the smart thing would be to call HR, they call you back. Because they don't always do that here. Uh they uh so that would be my starting point.

SPEAKER_05

But just plans are I'm looking it up. They are different. You see, this is the first time I've heard the question. Uh it it it it depends on the plan. It could become a loan offset, and then it's treated as taxable, as a taxable distribution, but doesn't have to be paid back.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, you can take money out for retirement while still having a loan in most plans. That's okay. I don't know that if you could take it from one and pay back the other, from like the pension, the uh money purchase pension plan and pay back the 401k, that I do not know. I think that would be plan dependent, but I could be wrong.

SPEAKER_05

It sounds like it.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, but this is something to work out, uh, especially if you're gonna be drawing before 59 and a half, because they're gonna be paying the penalty unless you take a even number of distribution even distributions.

SPEAKER_05

Okay, I'm just uh let me check that too.

SPEAKER_02

Uh it's kind of complicated, yeah.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, you you can you're allowed legally to use money purchase purchase pension plan money to repay a 401k loan. Um but generally speaking, those plans can't distribute funds before 62.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, okay. Which is gonna mess you up while you're still employed, though.

SPEAKER_05

Maybe after retirement, though, it yeah. After retirement or separation from service, usually you can take them out. Um you can rob Peter to pay Paul? Yeah, apparently you can.

SPEAKER_02

Okay.

SPEAKER_05

Um Yeah. Gee, this is really complicated.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, uh again, I don't know that we're gonna give you good advice here because every plan is a little bit different.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, and you're gonna call this. This should be a really simple question for your plan administrator.

SPEAKER_02

Yep.

SPEAKER_05

Because they this is something that this is their job. That's pretty much all their job is. Are is this stuff allowed by law? Yes. Will your plan allow it?

SPEAKER_02

Who knows? But it's not their only job. We ours just last week had a employee survey. Well, it's one of those. They surveyed all of us. By the way, if you filled out the survey and we got a certain amount of participation, every person got a $25 gift certificate to DoorDash. Who ever seen that? I used my $25 gift certificate to do that. Oh, you got one. No, everybody got one.

SPEAKER_05

You should have got one too. I didn't get one.

SPEAKER_02

Guess what it bought me, though. You're gonna laugh. You're using it.

SPEAKER_05

Well, it doesn't buy you much after the fees and the tip.

SPEAKER_02

$25 bought me a sandwich.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

It'll get you some a bag of chips and a cookie. And delivery.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah, no, I got nothing. Wow. Dude, I got no DoorDash thing.

SPEAKER_02

Message received. Ah, okay.

SPEAKER_05

Let's go to another question. I I don't know who I am. I'm just kind of out here on the periphery. And I float around the edges of the company, I do my little podcast.

SPEAKER_02

It's the edge of the universe.

SPEAKER_05

And then I go in then I then I go in my booth and record a short story. Oh, by the way, I just did a new I just did a new uh original short story yesterday. I love this short story because I worked really hard on it. I was thinking a while back, I was thinking about I think about these weird things, because you know me. I'm just a weird one. I know you do.

A Cosmic Extinction and a Short Story

SPEAKER_05

And I was thinking about what if there you know how how they they've talked about planet-wide extinction kind of events? And I thought, what if there was some force in the universe that hasn't hit us yet, but that might hit us someday and just destroy all life on the planet, all of it, including bacterial, the whole kit and caboodle. And so I came up with this story that's based on science. I did so much, it was so much fun science research into neutrinos and the big bang, or as some call it, the big bounce. You know, there may have been a big bounce where there was a universe. it collapsed and then it exploded again and all this really cool cosmological stuff. So I wrote a short story called Uh Final Shift. And it it's one of I I really enjoyed doing it. It was one of my favorites. I enjoyed it. So check that out. That's at litreading.com.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah when I think about the end of my life I think final it starts with SH, but we'll leave it at that. All right, uh Steve from Yardley, Pennsylvania.

Listener Q&A: Paying Roth Conversion Taxes

SPEAKER_02

News? Good. Thank you for all your information to provide. My questions about Roth conversions and how best to pay the associated taxes. My wife and I are both 58. So you got till 75 to worry about it.

SPEAKER_05

Well we're talking about yeah we're talking about an uh avoiding the the RMD we'll get to this in a moment.

SPEAKER_02

She retired this year I'm likely going to follow next year. How you people are retiring in your 50s what's that like I think it would be boring as hell the aforementioned paddle board and cold lake. We currently have about 300 I see people out there in the winter.

SPEAKER_05

We don't paddle board here because of giant dinosaurs. Come on snap you right up for the three I'd rather fall in a cold lake than a giant dinosaur infested lake.

SPEAKER_02

And that was a summer we currently have about my feet did you? Yeah. Okay. I'll I'm gonna believe you if you told me that uh we currently have 300,000 in Roth IRAs more than five million in traditional 401ks or iris in 401ks so you got kind of a not a great balance between pre-tax and post-tax got it planning to make some large Roth conversions before claiming Social Security at age 70. And by the way just full stop here it might make sense depending on your income for one person to go ahead and take Social Security at 62 and the bigger earner to wait till 70. Don't you both don't have to wait till 70 but that's a number to run and look at carefully. Continuing with the question I know you've said that taxes on Roth conversion should be paid from brokerage accounts or cash which we could comfortably do. However if a primary reason for the conversion is reduce traditional IRA Roth balance IRA and 401s why wouldn't it make sense to pay the taxes from those accounts as well?

SPEAKER_05

Because you lose the tax advantage growth tax free tax free growth in the raw well you lose yeah you lose the tax free growth of those dollars that you pay to the government.

SPEAKER_02

Instead of putting in 100,000 you're putting in 7500 to go to work for that doesn't make sense it's a bad idea. Yeah it is so if you're and by the way if you're just looking to have less in retirement I've got some people you know that that you could give the money to then you'd have a less of a RMD to to pay on later on. Now I mean all kidding aside it's yes you do. Ah they're the ones out there wrestling the alligators so it would it make sense no is it a good good method of doing it no it's not no and you're not just trying to reduce your RMD what you're really trying to do is balance out how your income's going to pay you over the next in your case 35 okay well like here's here's the here's a number for you I just ran a number.

SPEAKER_05

So let's say you're doing a $100,000 IRA withdrawal 24% rate the the account can grow at 7% for the next 10 years. Let's just use that number say that again now it's a it's a hundred thousand moving into a Roth yep okay 24% tax rate 7% annual growth for the 10 years is what our estimation is going to be. Okay?

SPEAKER_02

Yep.

SPEAKER_05

The if you pay the taxes after 10 years, if you pay the taxes from the IRA the Roth will be worth $149,000. That's if you pay the tax the actual tax money right if you pay the taxes externally your Roth will be worth $10,000 and you will have paid twenty four thousand in taxes so you will have a couple of hundred thousand or ten thousand the Roth will be worth $10,000? No hundred Roth the Roth will be worth $196,000.

SPEAKER_02

Okay so the the delta between the two is substantial.

SPEAKER_05

It's substantial it's five it's a nice five figure amount.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah.

SPEAKER_05

It's not sneeze at money. And that's just over ten years. If we're looking at over twenty before you withdraw well yes like with a Roth you can let it go forever.

SPEAKER_02

Yep.

SPEAKER_05

With a over twenty the difference is two hundred and ninety-four to three hundred and eighty seven almost a hundred K.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah so substantial yeah it Robert it's not the best way to do things and all of these Roth conversions I just wrote a great piece the other day I think this is one of those things everybody loved like oh I'll just get rid of my my uh my RMDs reduce those which sounds great but this should be done carefully should be done year by year and probably this is not a promotion probably reviewed by a professional yeah I mean although I think it's a pr this one's a pretty this one you don't need you don't need that. If this is a a no problem I can tell you no but I'd still if I was going to do conversions I'd still have somebody else and remember at age 75 this is not a very big deal.

SPEAKER_05

The the RMD percentage is four percent four percent.

SPEAKER_02

It's a little less than that three point six but yeah no no that's at 73 well he doesn't have to start till seventy five seventy five which is going to mean it's gonna be about four I think oh I see so they do they do increase it by the fact that the US until seventy five okay I just knew the first year of RMDs is about three point six something so now it's saying hold on I just pulled up the IRS thing 3.77. Okay. So we split it down the middle there.

SPEAKER_05

Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

There you go. Okay.

SPEAKER_05

That's it that's all right because they base it on life expectancy years. They use the uh IRS uniform lifetime table so at 75 you're considered to have a year less.

SPEAKER_02

And if they knew me they'd be making me take out like 60% this year because they know how short my well you because you keep going out and referring soccer games in your dotage it does look like dotage too trust me.

SPEAKER_05

I cannot imagine at my age running up and down a soccer field.

SPEAKER_02

Some lady the other day goes you really got your exercise and actually all fairness nah it was a pretty easy game I thought no I've done some games where I did but this wasn't one of them but do they allow segues? That's a good idea.

SPEAKER_05

Assistance devices of any kind of me on one of those things? Nah that doesn't mean oh wait wait they have those exoskeletons I just saw a guy review one of those exoskeletons. We saw one of those you could get really big baggy pants and just put it under your pants and have your little exoskeleton helping you up and down the field.

SPEAKER_02

I'm saying I'm headed there not there

Wrap-Up, Listener Questions, and Sign-Off

SPEAKER_02

yet it's not pushing all right you have questions for us?

SPEAKER_05

Well hopefully we have answers and by the way the real need is for that Friday QA show because if I don't get four more questions Christmas is canceled that's it. We're gonna cancel Christmas QA's oh the good news is though yes Mr Scrooge both shh both Christmas and New Year's Day fall on Fridays so there will be no Friday QA's on those days. Ooh look at you this is good for me not for you but it's good for me. Yeah well it's all good for me one more no you're still going to Hawaii said it's all good for me. And that's just a few weeks away can't wait to get out of this oh you're gonna go on the paddle board in Hawaii yeah so I may get eaten by a great white there so who knows right better than the gators thanks for listening go to talkingrealmoney.com to send in those questions please follow us on your favorite podcast service Telefriend or 10 um and become a follower become a follower and in the in light we're like a cult become one of our followers in the light of the theme of the program become a camp follower how's that go that's good with the are you doing the cowboy thing? Well you we started with the cowboy thing we end with the cowboy thing it's pretty well we always end with the cowboy thing because because I end the show with part of the song when it you know when I say at the end of the show we're talking about

Important Financial Disclosures

SPEAKER_05

the opinions of views expressed on this podcast were current on the date recorded.

SPEAKER_00

Opinions, estimates, forecasts and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and our subjects change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Apellow. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money is for informational, educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead the program is provided as a public service by Apello Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Apello Wealth ADB Part 2A on our website for information regarding Apello's fees and services. Apello Capital L L C D B A Apello Wealth is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training appello does not provide tax or legal advice and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening and please visit talkingrealmoney.com for more information and important disclosure related to performance of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast.